| Primary seal-strength result | ASTM F88/F88M measures the force required to separate a flexible package seal. The standard provides a test method and does not establish one universal pass/fail strength value. | Average force in N/15 mm or N/25.4 mm, according to the laboratory specimen width | 12.4 N/15 mm Review for demanding packs | 18.7 N/15 mm Suitable for general food packs | 24.1 N/15 mm Strong process capability |
| Minimum seal-strength result | Minimum values help identify weak sections that may be hidden by a satisfactory average. Test strips should be taken from multiple locations across the package. | Lowest recorded force from the defined sample set | 8.1 N/15 mm | 14.6 N/15 mm | 20.3 N/15 mm |
| Seal-strength consistency | Repeated ASTM F88/F88M measurements can be used to assess process variation, although the standard itself does not define a required coefficient of variation. | Coefficient of variation (CV) for a qualified sample set | 18.2% High variation | 9.4% Controlled variation | 5.8% Highly consistent |
| Seal failure mode | Record whether the specimen separates at the seal interface, tears through the package material, or shows mixed failure. Failure mode provides important information beyond force alone. | Visual classification after peel testing | 72% adhesive/interface separation 28% mixed failure | 38% adhesive/interface separation 62% material or mixed failure | 21% adhesive/interface separation 79% material or mixed failure |
| Seal-width uniformity | ASTM F88/F88M evaluates seal strength; seal width and appearance should also be documented because an irregular seal can produce misleading or variable results. | Target width: 5 mm; record the narrowest and widest sections | 3.1–5.8 mm Inconsistent width | 4.6–5.4 mm Within operating target | 4.8–5.2 mm Highly uniform |
| Temperature stability | Test results should be linked to the sealing conditions used during package preparation. Stable heat is essential for repeatable seal formation. | Temperature deviation from set point during a 30-minute run | ±9.0°C | ±3.5°C | ±1.8°C |
| Dwell-time control | Document the sealing time used to produce each specimen. A change in dwell time can materially affect seal strength, especially for heat-sensitive films. | Set-point deviation from nominal dwell time | ±0.20 s | ±0.08 s | ±0.03 s |
| Seal-pressure uniformity | ASTM F88/F88M does not prescribe a machine pressure value. Consistent contact pressure is nevertheless necessary to reduce channels, wrinkles, and localized weak seals. | Pressure variation across the sealing zone | ±22% | ±11% | ±6% |
| Leakage screening | Seal-strength testing and leak testing measure different characteristics. Use a complementary leak test to identify packages that may pass a force test but still contain channels or pinholes. | Failed packages in a 500-pack production trial | 14 packs 2.8% leakage | 5 packs 1.0% leakage | 1 pack 0.2% leakage |
| Throughput capacity | ASTM F88/F88M is a laboratory seal-strength method and does not rate production speed. Throughput should be evaluated without sacrificing the validated sealing window. | Finished packages per minute at the documented seal settings | 18 packs/min | 32 packs/min | 55 packs/min |
| Recommended qualification plan | Use the same film structure, package geometry, conditioning period, specimen width, test speed, and sampling plan for every machine comparison. | Minimum practical comparison | Test 30 packages across three operating shifts | Test 30 packages across three operating shifts | Test 60 packages across three operating shifts |
| Business suitability | Select the machine using validated seal-strength data, leakage performance, operating cost, required speed, package material, and the consequences of seal failure. | Practical recommendation | Best for low-volume, low-risk dry goods | Best balance for routine food production | Best for high-volume or high-consequence applications |