| Typical Product Range | Square: 15–50 mm Rectangular: 20 × 15–60 × 40 mm | Square: 20–100 mm Rectangular: 25 × 20–120 × 60 mm | Square: 40–150 mm Rectangular: 50 × 30–180 × 100 mm | Square: 100–250 mm Rectangular: 120 × 80–300 × 200 mm |
| Common Material | Low-carbon steel strip; galvanized strip may require suitable tooling and weld protection | Low-carbon and HSLA steel, subject to mill design and material certification | Low-carbon and HSLA steel with controlled yield strength and strip quality | Structural carbon steel and selected HSLA grades; confirm forming force and weldability |
| Typical Wall Thickness | 0.8–2.5 mm | 1.0–4.0 mm | 1.5–6.0 mm | 3.0–10.0 mm |
| Forming Method | Roll forming from round tube, followed by square sizing; economical for thin-wall products | Roll forming from strip to round tube, then forming into square or rectangular sections | Direct square or combined forming may be used to reduce deformation in medium-size products | Direct forming or heavy-duty breakdown and sizing passes; requires higher forming torque |
| Forming Pass Arrangement | Usually 12–18 forming and sizing stations | Usually 16–24 forming and sizing stations | Usually 20–30 stations, depending on product range and forming strategy | Usually 24–36 heavy-duty stations with reinforced frames and guides |
| Strip Entry Width | Approx. 50–160 mm, depending on section and wall thickness | Approx. 70–320 mm | Approx. 150–520 mm | Approx. 350–1,000 mm |
| High-Frequency Welding | Solid-state HF welding, commonly 60–150 kW | Solid-state HF welding, commonly 100–250 kW | Solid-state HF welding, commonly 200–400 kW | Solid-state HF welding, commonly 300–600 kW or more |
| Weld Seam Control | Impedance or induction welding with squeeze-roll adjustment and external bead removal | Automatic weld-centering, squeeze-roll control, bead scarfing, and basic weld monitoring | Closed-loop weld control, improved coil tracking, bead scarfing, and optional weld inspection | High-force squeeze rolls, advanced seam tracking, heavy-duty scarfing, and documented weld monitoring |
| Typical Line Speed | 30–60 m/min Best suited to small sections and moderate wall thickness | 40–80 m/min Balanced speed for common construction and fabrication sizes | 60–120 m/min Highest speeds generally apply to smaller sizes and thinner walls | 30–70 m/min Speed is limited by section size, wall thickness, and forming load |
| Speed Selection Factor | Small diameter, thin wall, steel grade, weld power, and cutoff cycle | Product dimensions, strip quality, weld stability, sizing accuracy, and changeover time | Acceleration control, coil-end welding, accumulator capacity, weld monitoring, and cutoff synchronization | Forming torque, weld heat input, tube straightness, saw capacity, and handling stability |
| Sizing Accuracy Target | Typically ±0.30 to ±0.50 mm for side dimension, depending on product standard | Typically ±0.20 to ±0.40 mm | Typically ±0.20 to ±0.35 mm with optimized tooling and process control | Typically ±0.30 to ±0.60 mm because of larger sections and greater forming forces |
| Sizing and Straightening | Final sizing rolls with adjustable side guides and light straightening | Multiple sizing stands, vertical and horizontal adjustment, and straightening section | Precision sizing stands, automated adjustment options, and high-speed straightening | Heavy-duty sizing rolls, reinforced guides, and controlled straightening for large profiles |
| Cutting System | Flying cold saw or flying shear; suitable for standard fixed lengths | Flying cold saw for clean ends and reduced deformation | High-speed flying cold saw with encoder synchronization and automatic length control | Heavy-duty flying cold saw; larger blade diameter and higher cutting torque are required |
| Typical Cut-Length Tolerance | Approximately ±1.0–2.0 mm, depending on length and machine setup | Approximately ±0.5–1.5 mm | Approximately ±0.5–1.0 mm with calibrated encoder and synchronized saw | Approximately ±1.0–2.0 mm because of section inertia and cutting force |
| Automatic Changeover | Manual roll and guide adjustment; economical for fewer product changes | Manual or semi-automatic adjustment with digital position indicators | Motorized roll adjustment and recipe-based setup can reduce changeover time | Usually manual or semi-automatic due to large tooling weight and high forming forces |
| Typical Coil Weight | Up to approximately 3–5 tonnes | Approximately 5–10 tonnes | Approximately 8–15 tonnes | Approximately 10–25 tonnes, subject to uncoiler and plant limits |
| Recommended Production Profile | Small batches, furniture components, light frames, and small structural tubes | General construction, greenhouse frames, machinery frames, and fabrication workshops | High-volume construction tube, racking, automotive components, and standardized profiles | Heavy structural frames, infrastructure components, large supports, and industrial fabrication |
| Main Advantage | Lower investment, compact footprint, and simpler operation | Good balance between product flexibility, speed, and operating cost | High output potential from 60–120 m/min for suitable products | Strong forming capability for large and thick-walled sections |
| Main Limitation | Limited section size, wall thickness, and high-speed production capability | May require tooling changes for a wide size range | Higher investment, stricter setup requirements, and greater demand for automation | Lower line speed and higher power, tooling, and floor-space requirements |
| Key Selection Check | Confirm minimum section size, HF power, and availability of suitable small-diameter tooling | Match the machine range to the most frequently produced sizes rather than the maximum advertised size | Verify actual speed at the required wall thickness, not only the no-load or minimum-size speed | Check forming torque, frame rigidity, weld power, saw capacity, and material handling limits |