| 1 | Product Grade Coverage | 15% | Number of high-carbon grades and equivalent designations offered | Coverage of carbon levels above approximately 0.60%, including grades such as 65Mn, 70, 75, 80 and 85 | GB/T 1222 for spring steel; GB/T 711 and customer-approved specifications | Critical |
| 2 | Chemical Composition Control | 14% | Heat-by-heat laboratory results for carbon, manganese, silicon, sulfur and phosphorus | Results within the agreed grade tolerance, with sulfur and phosphorus controlled to the applicable specification | Mill test certificates, spectrometer records and GB/T 223 chemical-analysis methods | Critical |
| 3 | Dimensional Accuracy | 12% | Thickness, width, flatness, crown and coil shape consistency | Conformance to the ordered tolerance under GB/T 709 or the buyer's approved dimensional schedule | Calibrated gauges, statistical process control records and inspection reports | Critical |
| 4 | Heat Treatment Capability | 11% | Availability of annealing, spheroidizing, normalizing or controlled cooling | Documented thermal-cycle control and stable hardness or microstructure results across the coil | Hardness testing, metallographic examination and process traceability records | Critical |
| 5 | Mechanical Performance | 11% | Tensile strength, yield strength, elongation, hardness and bending performance | All reported values meet the ordered grade and delivery condition without abnormal variation | GB/T 228.1 tensile testing, GB/T 231.1 Brinell hardness and applicable product standard | Critical |
| 6 | Surface and Internal Quality | 10% | Scale, cracks, laminations, inclusions, rust and edge-condition control | No rejectable surface defects; internal quality verified when required by ultrasonic or inclusion testing | Visual inspection, ultrasonic testing where specified and inclusion-rating records | High |
| 7 | Production Capacity and Delivery | 9% | Monthly rolling capacity, minimum order quantity and on-time delivery performance | Capacity suitable for repeat orders, documented lead times and reliable export packing capability | Production records, shipment history, capacity statement and customer references | High |
| 8 | Quality Management and Traceability | 8% | Traceability from raw material heat to finished coil and complaint-response capability | Valid quality-management certification, retained inspection records and identifiable coil or heat numbers | ISO 9001:2015 certificate, quality manual, corrective-action records and mill test certificates | High |
| 9 | Export Compliance and Packaging | 5% | Export documentation, seaworthy packing, marking and container-loading procedures | Moisture-resistant packaging, secure strapping, clear coil identification and complete shipping documents | Packing specification, commercial documents, inspection certificate and applicable customs requirements | Medium |
| 10 | Total Cost and Technical Support | 5% | Total delivered cost, technical communication, sampling and after-sales response | Competitive landed cost without reducing grade compliance, documentation quality or service reliability | Formal quotation, sample approval, technical data sheet and documented service response time | Medium |